You must login (register) to review.
Title: Birth of a pantypooper Reviewer: Jimmy Olsen Signed
I really liked this chapter. I can't think of any real suggestions.

The scene with Reiko waking up and passing gas is a good way to begin. The character gets a nice introduction and explanation. There is buildup toward the climax from the very beginning. The climax is amazing, of course. The half-deliberate accident is very detailed, and you describe it cleverly. I like the irony of the line, "Just need to get up, and squat!"

A couple proofreading issues. You say "Reiko was beside herself" twice. I think "a bubbling warms" is supposed to be "a bubbling warmth."

I like this character, but I'm not sure what more you should do with her. It would be cool to see her almost get caught, either in a new chapter or an extended version of this chapter. For example, it would be cool if the door was opening just as she threw her panties away, giving her an adrenaline rush as she buried the evidence at the last possible moment.
Date: Aug 31, 2013 11:18 pm [Report This]
Title: Birth of a pantypooper Reviewer: Black Osprey Signed

I'm a big fan of the new chapter! This one was always a favorite of mine, and the origin story is definitely welcomed. I'm always interested as to why a Nyou-Character does what she does in the story, and this origin really patches it up. Nice work.

 As far as an ending goes, I think it was a nice touch. There was a little whimsy in it (or that's what I felt when I read it.) and gives the story a little bit of playfulness. Overall, very nice work :D 



Author's Response: Thanks. Glad you enjoyed it.
Date: Jul 23, 2013 08:45 am [Report This]
Title: A dark secret Reviewer: HaloAnime Signed
Finish It!
Date: Jan 05, 2011 03:45 pm [Report This]
Title: A dark secret Reviewer: Poowrite Signed
Not bad, like before I caught a few errors with the grammer and whatnot but it didn't detract much from the story.

I approve of the masturbation scene at the end. This is a story about a chick who gets hot from pooping herself. What do people do when they get horny ... they take care of it :).

Good work.

Author's Response: Exactly. Anyone whose read an Arthur Saxon story can attest to this. Glad you liked it, I was starting to wonder if I wouldn't get many reviews for this, what with the fact it's gotten a ton of reads already.
Date: Feb 25, 2009 12:39 am [Report This]
Title: A dark secret Reviewer: Jimmy Olsen Signed
There should be a "masturbation" warning for this. From pretty early on I was suspecting that her pantypoop would lead into that, and unfortuately my suspicion was correct. I never like reading about that thing, but I do think there are some enjoyable things to this story. You conjure up a strong image of your "leading lady." She's an interesting character who I can picture well from your descriptions, even though I don't remember seeing the pic that inspired this story. I'm even a little tempted to use this character.

Besides my dislike for masturbation, and the fact that this is more a scene than a story, my criticisms are minor. The part with the meeting seems out-of-place. I think you should have either removed it or expanded it into something more substantial. There was also one sentence that bothered me: "Ever since she was fourteen, Reiko enjoyed defecating, an act which she took great pleasure in." That seems redundant.

I think you do a fine job describing Reiko and her intentional "accident," and I would enjoy reading about her again, provided her secret pleasure doesn't reach such a height.

Author's Response:

Oh pish-posh, what's the harm in seeing a masturbation scene? It's a natural thing.

While I admit the story is short, I hardly think it's a scene. A 'scene' is something that occurs in one place and normally like an excerpt from a full story. The meeting could have been a bit longer, but I didn't want to take too much focus off of what she was planning to do. Besides, it was necessary to establish she's a hard worker who does her job, not just stare at reports then go home all of a sudden.

Date: Feb 22, 2009 05:32 am [Report This]
You must login (register) to review.