I thought we could use a list like this, partly because the "browse categories" function leaves out some of the contest entries. If anyone has any corrections or additions, please post that information.
Story Contest I: Impromptu Toilet+
Case Closed: Rachel's Crisis (Orpheum)*
Gohan and Videl's First Tender Moment (Poowrite)
Story Contest II: Unwanted Guest+
A Bender and Her Bowels (Poowrite)
Case Closed: Rachel's Crisis 2 (Orpheum)*
Gullwings Gotta Go (Omnipresent)
Story Contest III: Code Lyoko
Code Lyoko, Chapter 1: Potty Training Aelita (Orpheum)*
Code Lyoko, Chapter 2: Aelita's Discovery (Poowrite)
Code Lyoko, Chapter 3: Aelita (Anime Lover)
Story Contest IV: Super Powers vs. Bladder Desperation Problem
Desperate Times (Orpheum)
The Lights Go Down (Jimmy Olsen)*
A Matter of Time (Poowrite)
Tales of Ba Sing Sa: Katara's Desperation (Anime Lover)
Story Contest V: Body Swap
Body Swap in the Hidden Leaf Village (Poowrite)*
A Strange Feeling (Orpheum)
Story Contest VI: Ghost Story
The Enema Ghost (Orpheum)
The Masterson Mausoleum (Poowrite)
An Otherworldly Walk-In (Micro)*
Re: Ghost Experience (Jimmy Olsen)
Story Contest VII: Holding Contest
The Contest: A SeeD vs. a Forest Owl (FallenStar)
My Life as a Succubus, Chapter 48: Karaoke Redux (Anime Lover)
Rikku's Desperate Gamble (Orpheum)*
Scat Fight, Round One: Tiffany vs. Tamara (Anime Lover)
Story Contest VIII: Utility Waste
A Fairy's Pee (Anime Lover)
The Frozen Prison (Jimmy Olsen)*
Story Contest IX: Giantess
Foul-ty Towers (Orpheum)
The Island of Moans (Jimmy Olsen)
Melina (Yarr)*
Story Contest X: Even Tough Chicks Have to Go Sometime
An Accident in Raccoon City (Poowrite)
One, then Two (Anime Lover)
Sometimes You Just Gotta Go (Orpheum)*
Story Contest XI: A Hard Day's Work
Lady Needs a Break (Orpheum)*
Videl's Fight (Poowrite)
What a Lousy Day for an Exorcism (Jimmy Olsen)
Story Contest XII: Halloween
A Bear Suit Yields Candy (Solomance)
By the Forest's Edge (Jimmy Olsen)*
Case Closed: Rachel's Crisis 3 (Orpheum)
Story Contest XIII: Still in Diapers
The Dirty Deal (Jimmy Olsen)*
A Gamer's Dedication (Anime Lover)
Story Contest XIV: Desperate Teacher
Hotaru Tomoe's Friends: Ami's Classroom Desperation (FallenStar)*
Story Contest XV: What Happened During...?
Ichigo Ramune (Kimiko)
It Wasn't Juice (Jimmy Olsen)
The Lost Tales (Orpheum)*
Story Contest XVI: Anything Goes
Dropping a Save (SharkBait)
Fast Food in the Feudal Era (JManime)*
The Ritual (Orpheum)
Writer's Blockage (Jimmy Olsen)
Story Contest XVII: Egg-Laying
Cylinder (Jimmy Olsen)
Inconvenience (Anime Lover)*
Story Contest XVIII: Magic Problems
Coe il Anthi's Curse (Jimmy Olsen)*
The Moon's Flow (EnragedFilia)
Overcharged (EagleWing)
The Wizard, the Dress and the Dilemma (Anime Lover)
Story Contest XIX: Adult Potty Training
The Little Selkie (Jimmy Olsen)
Re-Education (EagleWing)
Shapeshifter Training (EnragedFilia)*
Story Contest XX: A Big Girl Uses the Potty
Mother's Love (SakuraLover)
The Potty and the Spy (EnragedFilia)*
Sandy and Fate (Jimmy Olsen)
St. Catherine (EagleWing)
Story Contest XXII: Picture Story
Iboku's Day Out (Orpheum)
Maki's Little Secret: Revenge Gone Wrong (EnragedFilia)
A Tough Lesson (Jimmy Olsen)*
Story Context XXIII: Psychic Connection
Kerry Harper and the Messy Musical (EnragedFilia)
A Sensational Inconvenience (Anime Lover)*
Story Context XXIV: Litter Box Potty Time
Blessing or Curse? (EagleWing)
Genetic Infusion Chamber Experiment: Subject Felis01 (EnragedFilia)*
I've Come to Release (Erropai)
*winner
+not a complete list of entries
I think we can put a check next to me on contest 2 ;D I'm pretty sure I had it in the bag ^-^
Wow, 4 wins! That's half the contests that have been voted on. When you say you're pretty sure does that mean the voting didn't finish? I remember the site going down, was that when it happened?
Unfortunately the contest was still going when the original fiction site died, and we were starting 3 around the same time just to keep things rolling. But from what I can remember I pretty much had it in the bag as I recall having the most votes at that time.
By the way, you're forgetting Omnipresent's lost story "Gullwings Gotta Go", it was in the second contest. And I think there was a fourth story, but I can't remember.
Hopefully Duce might consider putting up a poll so we could get that contest resolved.
It may also be worth noting that contest #1 and contest #2 both had at least one more entry that were lost when the site died.
Contest #1 had a story where Yuna and Rikku use a blitzball and another one where Yuffie used Cloud O.o
Contest #2 had an entry from Omnipresent called "Gullwings Gotta Go," if I remember correctly and it seems like there was at least one more entry though I don't remember :/
Other than that, nice list.
Updated.
I still feel like I didn't win anything. :P
Seems like all my life, I only *technically* win when there's no one competing against me. It was like that back when I was on a swim team in my youth; I would normally be paired up against one other person and he'd always win, but when he wasn't around, I would win by default.
Seriously, that sucks, lol
How about something for Futanari?
Updated.
I can't speak for anyone else, but I hate futanari.
Updated.
Updated.
A belated update.
I think we should rearrange the contests a bit. Move XXII, XXIII and XXIV down by one each, so 22 is 21. I know that one had one entry and never finished, but I'd hate to see such an odd gap in the otherwise completed order. Though we could also just re-up 21 and give it a proper conclusion.
Overdue update. The 28th contest ended in a tie, right?